Production photo of Mere Waters produced by SheNYC Arts at The Connell
SheNYC
Production photo of Mere Waters produced by SheNYC Arts at The Connelly Theater in 2024. Photo credit: Danielle DeMatteo.
Seeking a new home after content restrictions at historic theater After eight years of championing gender equity in theater, SheNYC Arts—the premier organization producing work by women, trans, and nonbinary writers—is unexpectedly being forced to find a new venue. The historic Connelly Theater, where SheNYC Arts has produced its shows, has imposed content restrictions that bar performances on reproductive rights, trans issues, and gender equity, sparking concerns about censorship in one of the world’s most culturally progressive cities.
The Archdiocese’s New Content Restrictions
The decision stems from a shift in leadership within the Archdiocese of New York, which owns the Connelly Theater building. The new leadership has introduced strict guidelines, denying the space to productions that would be deemed inappropriate by the Catholic Church. According to SheNYC Arts, these restrictions include prohibiting shows that address reproductive rights or gender diversity.
“The Archdiocese specifically called out our past productions, labeling them ‘inappropriate’ for discussing issues like reproductive rights and gender,” said Danielle DeMatteo, Founder & Artistic Director of SheNYC Arts. “It’s shocking that in New York City, especially so close to an election that could determine the future of our rights, we’re seeing this kind of censorship.”
SheNYC audience members wait outside the Connelly Theater before a per
SheNYC
SheNYC audience members wait outside the Connelly Theater before a performance. Photo credit: John Crain
SheNYC audience members wait outside the Connelly Theater before a per
SheNYC
SheNYC audience members wait outside the Connelly Theater before a performance. Photo credit: John Crain
Standing Firm on Gender Equity
Despite the setback, SheNYC Arts is resolute in its mission. “We are deeply saddened to leave the Connelly, our home for nearly a decade, but we will not compromise on our values,” DeMatteo continued. “Our commitment to telling stories that champion gender equity remains unwavering.”
As the organization looks ahead to its 10-year anniversary in 2025, SheNYC Arts is actively seeking a new venue for its two-week summer theater festival, which attracted 2,000 attendees this past year. The festival, part of SheNYC’s broader nationwide programming, has reached over 35,000 audience members since its inception.
Call for Support and New Venue
Now, SheNYC Arts is turning to its community for help. The organization is calling for both financial backing and assistance in securing a new venue to continue its vital work. “This is a challenging moment, but it’s also an opportunity for growth and renewal,” DeMatteo said. “We’re incredibly grateful for the support we’ve received and invite anyone who believes in inclusive theater to join us.”
Those interested in supporting SheNYC Arts can visit shenycarts.org for more information on donations, sponsorships, and venue leads.
Production photo of Chasing Grace, A New Musical produced by SheNYC Ar
SheNYC
Production photo of Chasing Grace, A New Musical produced by SheNYC Arts at The Connelly Theater in 2023. Photo credit: Danielle DeMatteo
Production photo of Chasing Grace, A New Musical produced by SheNYC Ar
SheNYC
Production photo of Chasing Grace, A New Musical produced by SheNYC Arts at The Connelly Theater in 2023. Photo credit: Danielle DeMatteo
What's Next
As SheNYC Arts navigates this transition, it remains steadfast in its dedication to equity, inclusion, and artistic freedom. With the backing of a passionate community, the organization is confident it will continue to thrive and uplift underrepresented voices.
